Black Hole Friday$15 is stuck in orbit for 100 licensesuntil Nov 30Six codes escaped. Catch one.

Apple Remote Desktop vs Screen Sharing vs Remote Management

Updated · Dmytro Virych

Comparison · 6 min read · facts checked

Screen Sharing comes with macOS and lets you see and control another Mac. Apple Remote Desktop is a separate app from the Mac App Store for administering many Macs at once, and Remote Management is the switch that lets it in. To use one Mac of your own from another, Screen Sharing is enough.

Three names on a Mac sound like the same thing: Screen Sharing, Remote Management and Apple Remote Desktop. Two are switches in System Settings, one is an app from the Mac App Store, and only one of the switches can be on at a time. Here is which is which, and which a Mac mini and a MacBook of your own need. Each fact about Apple's software comes from Apple's own pages, listed under the post.

What is the difference between Apple Remote Desktop and Screen Sharing?

Screen Sharing shows one Mac's screen on another Mac and lets you control it. Apple Remote Desktop is for the person who looks after many Macs: its Mac App Store page describes managing the Mac computers on a network. Remote Management is not a third product. It is the switch that lets Apple Remote Desktop into a Mac.

Screen SharingApple Remote DesktopWormhole
What it isPart of macOS: a switch in Sharing settings, and an app in Applications › UtilitiesA separate app that Apple sells on the Mac App StoreA separate app for your own Macs (pricing)
Made forSeeing and controlling one other MacAdministering many Macs at onceOpening one window from another Mac as a window here, or its whole screen
Switch on the Mac you reachScreen SharingRemote ManagementShare this Mac's windows, in the app
On the Mac you sit atThe Screen Sharing app, already installedThe Apple Remote Desktop appThe same app
Who gets inThe users you allow, with a name and passwordThe users you allow, each limited to the tasks you chooseMacs you paired once, with the same six digits on both screens
From other kinds of computerVNC viewer apps, as an optionVNC viewer apps, as an optionNo: Mac to Mac only

What is the difference between Screen Sharing and Remote Management?

Both are switches in System Settings › General › Sharing, two of several ways into a Mac. Apple's guide gives each of these four a job:

SwitchWhat Apple says it is for
Screen SharingThe user of another computer sees your screen and can control your Mac
Remote ManagementA Mac that is remotely managed using Apple Remote Desktop
Remote LoginLogging in to your Mac from another location with SSH
Remote Application ScriptingResponding to Apple events sent from other computers

Remote Management turns on software that is already part of macOS. You decide who gets in: which users may connect, and what each may do. Apple lists the tasks one by one, among them observing the screen, controlling it, generating reports, opening and quitting applications, changing settings, copying items, and restarting and shutting down.

Can Screen Sharing and Remote Management both be on?

No. Apple's guide says the two cannot be on at the same time: Remote Management has to be turned off before Screen Sharing is turned on. That catches people out. One thread in Apple's community is titled with the message its writer was shown: "Screen sharing is currently being controlled by the remote management service".

To change from one to the other:

  1. On the Mac you want to reach, open System Settings, click General, then Sharing.
  2. Turn off Remote Management.
  3. Turn on Screen Sharing, click the Info button beside it, and choose who may connect under Allow access for.

Make the change while you are at that Mac: MacMiniVault, which hosts Mac minis, warns its customers that making it over the remote connection cuts that connection off.

If Remote Management is the one that is on, Apple's Remote Desktop guide has a note. When it was turned on with the kickstart command-line tool and not in Sharing settings, Screen Sharing gives view-only access on macOS 10.14 or later; to view and control, turn Remote Management off and on again in Sharing settings. The note implies that the Screen Sharing app reaches such a Mac, though Apple's guide does not say so outright.

Do I need Apple Remote Desktop to control my Mac mini from my MacBook?

No. Screen Sharing does that job, and both halves of it are already on your Macs: the switch on the Mac mini, and the Screen Sharing app in Applications › Utilities on the MacBook. How to control your Mac mini from your MacBook has the steps.

Some things people expect to need Apple Remote Desktop for come with Screen Sharing: Apple's guide describes a shared clipboard, and dragging files into and out of the screen sharing window. High Performance, the mode with higher frame rates, is documented for both apps with the same requirement: Apple silicon and macOS Sonoma 14 or later on both Macs.

From another network, the way to use Screen Sharing is over a VPN between the two Macs: see how to use Mac Screen Sharing over the internet.

What does Apple Remote Desktop add?

Its list is written for someone with many Macs to look after. From its App Store page:

  • Software distribution. Copying and installing software on remote Macs.
  • Administration. Locking screens, and putting Macs to sleep, waking, restarting and shutting them down.
  • Reports. Hardware reports, and reports on user logins and application use.
  • Assistance. Observing and controlling screens, with Curtain Mode, which stops the person at the Mac from seeing its screen while you control it.

The Macs it manages need Remote Management on, which Apple says an organisation's device management can also turn on.

Where does Wormhole fit?

Wormhole is a third kind of tool: an app for using your own Macs from each other, window by window. It uses neither service, so both switches can stay off.

  • What you see. Pick a window from the other Mac's list and it opens here as a window of its own, with its own Dock icon and ⌘Tab entry. Whole screen is in the same list.
  • Its own switch and pairing. A Mac shares only while Share this Mac's windows is on in the app's menu bar panel. Two Macs pair once, by confirming the same six digits on both screens. There is no account and no password.
  • Its own permissions. The Mac that shares needs Screen Recording, and Accessibility to take your clicks and typing; without Accessibility a window is view-only.
  • Its own connection. The two Macs connect directly, and every frame is encrypted end to end.

What it is not, and what has not been tried:

  • It is not an administration tool. It has no software distribution and no reports, and nothing like Curtain Mode: the window you click comes to the front on the other Mac's screen, where anyone in the room can see it.
  • It is Mac to Mac only, with the app on both (macOS 14 Sonoma or later, Apple silicon or Intel).
  • It runs inside your account. It cannot show a login window or unlock a locked screen, and while sharing is on it keeps that Mac awake and unlocked.
  • It has not been tested on a Mac mini with no display attached, and typing into password fields on the other Mac has not been tried yet.
  • Between two places it needs a route you run, such as Tailscale. That has been tried once, before version 1.4.1 and over a connection Tailscale relayed: the picture stuttered and fell behind. Version 1.4.1 adapts to a slow connection, measured so far on one desk only.

The known issues page keeps the full list, the setup guide covers pairing, and the free plan opens one remote window at a time (pricing).

Which one fits which job?

  • One Mac of your own, its whole desktop, now and then. Screen Sharing: it is already on both Macs.
  • Many Macs to look after. Apple Remote Desktop, with Remote Management on each of them.
  • A Mac your school or employer manages. Ask before turning Remote Management off: it may be how they reach it.
  • One app from the other Mac beside your own windows. That is the case Wormhole is for: see how it differs from Screen Sharing.
  • An iPhone, an iPad or a Windows PC at your end. Wormhole cannot do that. The other ways to reach a Mac are compared with their sources.

Questions people ask

Does Apple Remote Desktop have to be installed on both Macs?

No. Apple's guide says the Remote Desktop client software is installed by default in macOS. The app from the App Store goes on the Mac you manage the others from, and each Mac it manages has Remote Management turned on.

My Mac shows a Remote Management screen during setup. Is that this switch?

No. Setup Assistant has a pane with the same name. Apple's deployment guide says it cannot be skipped on a device that an organisation has registered with Apple and manages through a device management service. It is about who manages the device, not about the Sharing switch.

Is Remote Management safe to leave on?

Treat it as you would Screen Sharing. Apple's list of ports gives TCP port 5900 to both Apple Remote Desktop and Screen Sharing, and port 3283 to Apple Remote Desktop as well, so the same rule holds: keep those ports closed on your router. Is Mac Screen Sharing secure? goes through the settings.

#alternatives#apple

Sources