Black Hole Friday$15 is stuck in orbit for 100 licensesuntil Nov 30Six codes escaped. Catch one.

Can you drag a window between Macs with Universal Control?

Updated · Dmytro Virych

Guide · 6 min read

No. Universal Control moves your pointer, your typing and the files you drag between Macs, and each Mac keeps its own windows. To put a window on the other Mac's screen, extend your desktop to it with AirPlay; to use an app from the other Mac while it stays where it runs, use Screen Sharing or an app such as Wormhole.

Two Macs on one desk, Universal Control on: the pointer slides from one screen to the other, so it is natural to take a window by its title bar and drag it across too. It stops at the edge of the screen. Here is why, and the three things that do what the drag was reaching for. Each fact about macOS has its source under the post.

Can Universal Control move a window to another Mac?

No. Apple's guide to Universal Control says each device shows its own screen and apps. What the Macs share is one keyboard and one mouse or trackpad. Three things do cross from one Mac to the other:

  • The pointer, and your typing with it. Move the pointer slightly past the left or right edge of the screen and it carries on onto the other Mac.
  • Things you drag. Apple's page gives dragging files from one Mac to another as an example.
  • What you copy. Copy on one Mac and paste on the other.

A window stays behind because an app draws it, and the app runs on one of the two Macs. TidBITS said so when Universal Control arrived in 2022: each Mac runs independently and the second is not a display for the first, so you cannot drag a window from one Mac to another as you would to an external monitor.

What do you want the window to do on the other Mac?

Moving a window can mean three different things, and each has its own tool:

What you are afterWhat to useWhat moves
More room: this Mac's windows on that Mac's screenAirPlay, with that Mac as the displayThe window, onto a second screen of the same Mac
The same page or document, continued on the other MacHandoff, or drag the file acrossThe work. An app on the other Mac opens it
An app that stays on one Mac, used from the otherScreen Sharing, or WormholeA live picture of the window. The app keeps running where it is

How do I use the other Mac as a second display?

This is the one that makes the drag itself work: with the other Mac acting as a display, a window goes across as it would to any second monitor.

  1. On the Mac that will be the display, open System Settings, click General, then AirDrop & Continuity (AirDrop & Handoff on some versions), and turn on AirPlay Receiver. Allow AirPlay for sets who may send to it: Current User keeps it to devices signed in to your Apple Account.
  2. On the Mac whose windows you want to move, click Control Center in the menu bar, click Screen Mirroring, and choose the other Mac.
  3. Choose to use it as a separate display, not to mirror. Apple's guide says to follow the onscreen instructions to choose whether to share a window or to mirror or extend your Mac screen.
  4. Drag the window across.

Apple's guide writes steps 2 and 3 for a TV. TidBITS and MacRumors each tried them with a Mac at the other end, and one Mac's display could be mirrored or extended to the other. What it needs, and what it costs:

  • Recent Macs. Apple's requirements page lists AirPlay to Mac for macOS Monterey 12 or later, on a Mac mini from 2020 or later, an iMac Pro, or any other Mac from 2018 or later. Both Macs need Wi-Fi on and the same network.
  • That Mac is a display for the time being. AirPlay takes over its screen, and TidBITS notes that a Mac cannot be controlled through Universal Control while it is serving as another Mac's display.
  • The picture may disappoint. TidBITS tried it in 2022, on macOS Monterey, from a MacBook Air to a 27-inch iMac: at the iMac's native resolution everything was too small, and at 2560×1440 the picture was fuzzy. MacRumors reported that it also works over a USB cable between the two Macs, which Apple suggested for avoiding delay.

How do I carry on the same work on the other Mac?

Sometimes the window is only a means: you want the same page, message or document in front of you at the other Mac. That is Handoff. Apple's page says that when a task can be handed off, the Handoff icon of its app appears in the Dock of the other Mac; click it and carry on there. Apple lists Calendar, Contacts, FaceTime, Keynote, Mail, Maps, Pages, Numbers, Reminders and Safari, as well as many third-party apps.

Both Macs need Wi-Fi and Bluetooth on and the same Apple Account, and they have to be within 10 meters of each other. The switch is Allow Handoff between this Mac and your iCloud devices, in System Settings › General › AirDrop & Continuity. For anything Handoff does not cover, drag the file across with Universal Control, or copy and paste.

How do I use a window from the other Mac without moving the app?

Some apps have to stay where they are: installed on one Mac only, or with their project on that Mac's disk. Then what you want is a live view of the window on the Mac in front of you.

Screen Sharing, which comes with macOS, shows the other Mac's whole screen inside one window. The Mac mini guide has the steps, and how the two ways differ has its own page.

Wormhole shows one window, or the whole screen when you pick that. It opens a window from the other Mac as a window of its own here, with its own Dock icon and its own place in ⌘Tab, titled with the app and the Mac it runs on. You click, scroll and type into it, and resizing your copy resizes the real one. The window does not leave the first Mac: what you get is a live copy of it.

It takes the app on both Macs (macOS 14 Sonoma or later, Apple silicon or Intel), Local Network allowed on both, Screen Recording and Accessibility allowed on the Mac that shares, and one pairing: both screens show the same six digits, and there is no account. Then, on the Mac you want the window on, press ⌃⌥⌘Space, or choose Open a window… from the menu bar, and pick it. The setup guide has each step with pictures.

There is also a gesture that looks like the drag you tried. With Fling, you push a window against the left or right side of the screen on the Mac it lives on, hold it there for a moment, and it opens on your other Mac. Fling is off by default: switch it on in Settings › General on both Macs. It was tried between two Macs before it shipped in version 1.3.0, and worked.

What to know before relying on it:

  • Two things about Fling have not been checked. One is a pair of Macs with Universal Control linked across that same side, where the same push is how the pointer crosses. The other is window tiling: Apple's guide says macOS Sequoia 15 and later tile a window that is dragged to the edge of the screen and released (its switch is in System Settings › Desktop & Dock). If either gets in the way, open the window from the other Mac instead.
  • It gives the first Mac no extra room. The real window stays on that Mac's screen, so for a bigger desktop AirPlay is the tool.
  • Clicking your copy brings the real window to the front on the other Mac, because a click or a keystroke can only reach the window in front.
  • Five shortcuts stay on the Mac you type on: ⌘Q, ⌘H, ⌘M, ⌘Tab and ⌘`. ⌘Q closes your copy; ⌘W closes the real window.
  • Without Accessibility on the sharing Mac, the window is view-only.
  • Password fields, games and some Electron apps have not been tried yet.
  • It is Mac to Mac only, and the free plan opens one remote window at a time (pricing).

The known issues page has the rest, input methods among them.

Questions people ask

Does Sidecar work with a Mac as the second display?

No. Apple's Sidecar page is about using an iPad as a second display for a Mac; between two Macs the built-in way is AirPlay. Universal Control vs Sidecar vs Screen Sharing has what each one does and needs.

Does target display mode still work?

Only with old hardware. Apple's page lists certain iMac models from 2009 to mid 2014 running macOS High Sierra or earlier as the display, connected by a Thunderbolt or Mini DisplayPort cable to a Mac from 2019 or earlier running macOS Catalina or earlier.

Do both Macs need the same Apple Account?

For Universal Control and Handoff, yes. An AirPlay receiver can be opened to anyone on the same network, or to everyone, under Allow AirPlay for. Wormhole uses no account, only the six-digit pairing.

#guides#apple

Sources